Mixed outside storage

Causes of fire

The known causes of a number of major fires which have occurred over the years in South Africa involving outside storage, indicate a definite need for more effective control by management if they are to be avoided.

Some of these causes are listed below:

1. Sparks from an over-stacked waste incinerator ignited paper reel storage nearby.
2. Employees were cooking meals on open fires in a timer yard. The wind blew burning embers into sawdust which caught alight and in turn ignited the timber.
3. Sparks from a passing locomotive ignited long grass in which crates of costly machinery were lying.
4. A fire break was cut around a wire fence, but the cut grass was piled against the fence and grass within the grounds had not been removed. A fire of unknown origin ignited the grass and spread to combustible packaging stacked against the metal-clad building and through the open factory windows.
5. Combustible goods were stacked against corrugated asbestos cement walling of a warehouse. A fire, the cause of which was unknown, but probably deliberate, ignited these goods. The heat from the ensuing fire caused the asbestos cement wall cladding to disintegrate, permitting the fire to spread into the warehouse.

The most obvious lessons to be learnt from these occurrences are that adequate separation of combustible storage from buildings is essential. It is also important that vegetation be removed from within the fences, as well as a good distance on the outside. Stored goods should be limited in height and size to minimise the possibility of rapid fire spread and total involvement.

Recommendations

The following recommended storage practices are based on advice issued by the Factory Mutual Engineering Corporation of USA and are the results of analyses of numerous incidents over many years.

Paper rolls

Ideally outdoor storage of roll paper should be avoided because automatic sprinkler protection is impractical and because fires in yard storage may seriously expose nearby buildings. Outdoor storage is more exposed to sources of ignition than indoor storage, particularly to sparks from yard fires, nearby grass fires and deliberate ignition by intruders.  If ignition occurs, wind is often a serious factor in developing a fire, making extinguishment more difficult. In practice, of course, it is found that large quantities of paper and cardboard are stored outside.

Safeguards

1. Piles should be located at least 6m to 15m from main buildings, depending on height and size of piles and the total tonnage.
2. Piles should be limited to approximately 200 tonnes. They should be separated by clear spaces of at least 15m.
3. Roll paper in the yard should be stored on its side rather than on its end. This generally results in a less intense fire because there is less tendency for the rolls to unwind and the flue effect between stacks is reduced.
4. Height of piles should be limited to about 5m.
5. The entire storage area should preferably be paved or otherwise kept free of dried grass, debris and weeds, and should be protected against unauthorised entry.  Concrete slab fencing is preferable to wire mesh. A clear space of at least 15m should be maintained between public ways and piles.
6. Hydrants and hose protection should be provided. Hydrants should be located so that no part of the storage area is more than 60m from a hydrant.
7. A regularly recorded watch service should be provided to cover the entire area.
8. First-class housekeeping should be maintained throughout the storage area.
9. Smoking should be prohibited and other ignition sources eliminated from the vicinity of the storage area.
10. Spark arresting equipment should be installed on stacks from incinerators, locomotives and other spark-producing equipment.

Wastepaper

Economic considerations dictate that large quantities of wastepaper be stored outside.

Safeguards

1. Piles of wastepaper should be located from 6m to 15m from important buildings and plant facilities. Small piles one bale high are acceptable as close as 6m. For larger piles containing several hundred tonnes and 5m to 6m high, the 15m distance is needed.
2. Piles should be located at a safe distance (at least 15m) from public ways, incinerators, and other sources of ignition.
3. Separate piles by at least 15m of clear space.
4. Keep the entire storage area free of dried grass and weeds and protected against unauthorised entry.
5. Limit piles size to 750 tonnes (preferably to 500).
6. Limit pile height to 6m.

Coal

The storage method does much to determine whether spontaneous ignition will occur.

The following suggestions have been developed from experience and are applicable to most manufacturing plants:

1. Avoid storing the coal in contact with any course of external heat such as piping, flues and boiler walls, and over steam mains even though buried.
2. Limit the height of the pile. Low-grade coal should not be piled higher than 3m and best grade not higher than 5m, unless it is piled by the roll packing method. Roll packed piles should generally be limited to 6m in height. If large capacity coal handling equipment is available at all times, somewhat higher roll packed piles are allowable. High piling makes it difficult for heat to reach. Piles should be located a safe distance from other combustibles and from important plant buildings and equipment.

Cotton bales

If temporary outdoor storage of cotton bales is necessary, the following measures are recommended:

1. Outside stored bales should be the first ones to be used.
2. Outside storage piles should be limited to 500 bales per pile with a clear space of preferably 15m but not less than 10m between individual piles and between piles and buildings. Piles 3m to 5m high are convenient for handling and for weather covering.
3. Adequate hydrants and hoses should be provided to protect the outside storage.
4. Remove dead grass and loose combustible materials in the vicinity of the piles.
5. Institute an effective security system. Lower bales should be placed on dunnage to provide ventilation and prevent excess damage by ground moisture.

Sprinkler protected buildings

The Automatic Sprinkler Inspection Bureau, which inspects sprinkler installations for insurance discount purposes, has issued the following ruling regarding the minimum distance of combustible storage from sprinklered buildings:

• The distance between stacks of materials and buildings should be at least equal to the stack heights. For buildings of inferior construction, drenchers would be required below the eaves to protect the exposed face, but, where standard construction exists, only openings (windows and doors) need have cut-off drenchers.

Wood products

A fire once established in stacked timber is one of the most formidable with which fire-fighters have to contend. Intense radiant heat makes approach difficult and dangerous and seriously exposes surrounding property. Under unfavourable wind conditions, burning brands can start secondary fires considerable distances away.

It is important that fire in a timber yard be discovered and attacked without delay while still small. For this purpose an effective watch service, alarm system and a sizeable well-equipped and well-trained fire organisation is essential. For effective performance there should be close co-operation and advance planning between public and plant fire protection personnel. Containing a timber yard fire requires large quantities of water. It is important that there are sufficient hydrants connected to a reliable water supply with sufficient hoses to deliver the water where it is needed.

Careful attention to housekeeping and the elimination of ignition sources will reduce the chance of fire starting.

Reasons for fire spread in storage yards

• delayed discovery
• delayed fire-team response
• inadequate water supplies – large volumes are necessary for controlling and extinguishing fires involving wood products
• lack of hydrants
• undivided piles and congested storage
• poor fire-fighting techniques and access difficulties

Yard layout for forest products

• solid ground surfaced with fine gravel or stone
• stacking in a consistently orderly manner
• a maximum stack-height of 6m
• as a guide to the size of stacks, no part should be further than 15m from a fire lane, i.e. lanes permitting the passage of fire vehicles
• demarcating posts to limit stack sizes and indicate boundaries of stacks
• protection of buildings in the vicinity of the yard either by separation, fire-resisting construction, or by drencher systems.

Wood chip piles should preferably be limited to 15m in height. This pile is too large and if alight, would be almost impossible to control.

Poles & posts

These are usually stacked in ranked piles or in crib formation. Flat crib style stacking without any space between stacks – so forming solid packed rows – requires unobstructed alleys of 1,5m width which permits fire-fighters access with hand-held hoses. Open stacks, which would allow hose streams to penetrate, need only have an aisle every alternate row of post stacks. Where it is not practical to provide aisles of 1,5m width between each row, the length of the rows should be reduced by 20% - 50 % to reduce fire loading and to facilitate fire-fighting.

Treated posts and poles should not be stored in the same stacks as untreated products. Separation distances of at least 30m will reduce the possibility of fire spread from one such area to the other.

Wood chips and wood waste material

Additional controls to monitor spontaneous heating of piles may have to be employed. Surface and internal fires are a possibility and the internal pile temperature may require monitoring.


Prevention of internal pile fires

• avoid burying refuse and old chips in the pile base
• prepare a clean, hard surface before starting a pile
• regular reclamation of the piles – the period will vary depending upon climatic conditions and pile contents
• limitation of pile size. Several small piles are safer than one large pile. Special consideration to the pile height, especially if fine materials are stored in the pile and are subjected to compaction. For example, wood chip piles should preferably be limited to 15m in height.
• monitor internal pile temperatures regularly during pile build-up
• fines present the most serious hazard during building up of the pile – their concentration should be controlled

Consideration for protecting piles

• narrow piles are easier to extinguish and maximum dimensions should ideally be 19m high 90m wide and 150m long
• piles exceeding 150m in length should be sub-divided by fire lanes of at least 9m wide
• low barrier walls will aid in defining the pile boundaries
• combustible conveyors and elevated enclosed conveyors feeding the pile should be protected by sprinklers

Logs and lumber

These are usually stored in ranked (evenly arranged) piles and separated by aisles with a width of either 6m or 1½ times the height of the pile. Fire breaks 30m wide between alternate rows of pile groups and pile lengths not exceeding 150m, will allow fire-fighters access.

Water supplies

• Hydrants should be a maximum distance of 60m apart at aisle intersections so that two lengths of hose will reach any area of the yard (see photo). If stacks obstruct the hydrants, elevated markings on poles showing hydrant location should be utilised.
• Water requirements are based upon 4 x 65mm hose lines being used simultaneously with a residual mains pressure of 140kPa. A combined flow of 4 500/min should be expected with supplies sufficient for six hours.

Crib stacking of lumber in this scene creates an unnecessary exposure hazard to the timber-clad buildings. Also the sprinkler system feed pipe will be at risk of collapse or damage in the event of fire

Safeguards

• The premises should be adequately fenced to keep out intruders.
• Spark arresters should be installed on any spark producing chimneys in the vicinity of timber yards.
• The burning of rubbish or open fires for cooking should be strictly forbidden.
• Extinguishers should be provided on forklift trucks and other power-driven equipment.
• Good housekeeping is essential – regular cleaning of materials i.e. handling equipment, removal of combustible waste (bark, sawdust, chips) etc. Remove grass, weeds and rubbish in the yard and on the boundaries.
• No smoking must be enforced except in designated safe areas away from mills and yard.

Protection of exposures

• Separate yard areas and operations. Separation distance depends upon severity of the risk which varies according to area, height and occupancy, construction and the type of stacking.
• Separation of piles and stacks from each other and plant buildings should prevent fire spread through radiated heat, but flying brands can still spread fire. One or more of the following may protect plant buildings and reduce fire spread:
  • barrier walls to protect buildings
  • perimeter stacking equivalent to a barrier wall, i.e. materials of greatest thickness and green stock
  • drencher systems especially designed to protect exposed structures

Fire detection and extinguishing considerations

• Early detection is vital and the emphasis should be on regular watchman patrols and an alarm system. Extra patrols during dry weather should be considered.
• The establishment of a trained fire-team and regular drills to maintain competency is vital.
• Procedures must be practised for notifying fire brigade and plant fire-teams. In remote areas, an alarm linked to the mill’s township might result in quicker response of additional fire teams – if pre-planned. Easy access to fire lanes for fire-fighting vehicles is vital.
• Maintain fire-fighting equipment and keep records of standard tests. Replacement equipment should be readily available and all designated fire-fighting equipment must be used for that purpose only. Too often hose-reels and fire hose are used for washing vehicles and other extraneous purposes, causing deterioration and damage.
  

  Good housekeeping, neat stacking, an adequate hydrant system properly demarcated,
  are all features of this well-managed log storage yard.

  
  Reference

  NFPA 46: Storage of forest product

  Published by:
  Fire Protection Association of Southern Africa
  (Incorporated Association not for Gain)
  (Reg.No. 73/00022/08)
  P O Box 15467
  Impala Park
  1472

  
  Mixed_Outside_Storage.pdf

People in Risk

Marcel Wood

Marcel Wood heads Etana’s risk management division. Before starting in insurance he worked for the fire department, rescuing people and (literally) putting out fires. He’s passed through Munich Re and Santam, and has designed the only risk management tool aimed specifically at the insurance industry – ARQ. Marcel is a mean guitarist, a brilliant vocalist and an accomplished soccer player with the personal motto: “Do your best all the time”.